The Ultimate Guide to Starting a Membership Site (2023)

Are you interested in creating a WordPress membership site? It’s a worthwhile venture! 

Membership sites are an excellent way for businesses to provide customers with long-term value while generating recurring revenue and growth. 

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about making a membership site, including choosing the right platform, exploring various membership models, and creating and marketing members-only content.

So, if you’re ready to launch a successful membership site that caters to your target audience, let’s dive in!

Choosing the right membership model

Selecting the right paid membership model is crucial to the success of your membership site. 

A membership model can provide value to your audience and benefit your business by maximizing your efforts.

The model you choose also determines the type of content, pricing strategy, and overall experience offered to your members – so it’s essential to identify your audience’s specific needs and wants before deciding.

Pros and cons of different membership types

There are various membership models available, each with its pros and cons. 

It’s well worth taking the time to consider each model’s benefits to make an informed decision about which is the best fit for your membership site.

1. Content-based membership

This model offers exclusive access to premium content like articles, videos, and podcasts. 

As a result, you’ll be able to generate income by monetizing your expertise and knowledge – and provide value to your members. 

However, content-based memberships require constant content creation to keep members engaged and subscribed.

2. Course-based membership

A course-based membership model provides access to online courses and educational materials. 

With the potential for higher revenue and the ability to scale, this model can be an attractive option for many businesses, although the time and effort required to create and update courses can be a significant drawback for some.

3. Community-based membership

By nurturing an active community of members who interact with and support each other, this membership model can be a rewarding way to boost engagement and loyalty. 

On the other hand, active moderation and management are required to maintain a positive and productive community environment, which can be time-consuming.

4. Service-based membership

A service-based model offers access to premium services, like coaching and consulting – and the subsequent potential for higher revenue and personalized offerings makes this an appealing membership option. 

Scalability is limited due to time constraints, however, as it can be challenging to serve a large number of members simultaneously.

There’s a lot to consider before you select a membership model. 

Consider your target audience, personal know-how, and overall business goals when weighing your options. 

If you align these factors with the right model, you can create a membership site that’ll provide upskilling services for your audience and support the growth of your business.

Selecting the perfect platform or plugin

The membership program you choose will significantly impact other aspects of your service – including the ease of use of your site as well as its functionality, customization options, and scalability. 

As a result, it’s better to make your final decision once you’ve vetted several potential platforms and membership plugins.

When considering your options, you’ll want to asses key pain points, like difficulties configuring the technical aspects of the site and membership content generation.

There are several factors to keep in mind when selecting a platform, plugin, or add-on: 

  1. Ease of use and setup
  2. Integration with other tools and services (such as CRM and email automation)
  3. Community group customization options
  4. Scalability and growth potential
  5. Pricing and affordability

Why AccessAlly is the ideal solution

While many membership platforms are available, AccessAlly stands out from the crowd. 

The WordPress plugin makes it possible to create and manage membership sites, scale your business, and provide an outstanding learning experience to your audience.

Here are just a handful of AccessAlly’s powerful features:

1. Comprehensive functionality

AccessAlly offers a range of tools to help users build, sell, and grow their services – from online courses to coaching and membership offerings.

Membership features include a flexible course builder, cross-selling member dashboards, personalized automation, one-click upsells, bulk course enrollment, and gamification elements.

2. Ease of use and setup

You don’t need to be a technical wizard to make the most of AccessAlly’s membership functionality. 

The plugin is designed for user-friendliness, meaning that any entrepreneur, small business owner, content creator, or educator will have no trouble setting up and managing an eLearning site.

3. Integration with other tools and services

AccessAlly seamlessly integrates with popular CRMs, email marketing platforms, payment gateways (like PayPal and Stripe), and other tools. 

This allows site owners to streamline their membership site management and marketing operations.

You’ll even be able to accept recurring payments from your learners, as AccessAlly is compatible with various payment methods (including credit cards). 

4. Customization and scalability

With AccessAlly’s flexible course builder (and other handy features, including a sleek WordPress theme), it’s possible to customize the learning experience to suit your audience’s needs.

Plus, AccessAlly can help your business scale as your membership site grows and evolves.

5. Cross-selling member dashboards

Dashboards are a must-have for creators selling more than one course. 

With AccessAlly’s dashboards, you can showcase exclusive content to free and paid members, and help customers find all of your offerings.

Centralizing your courses allows customers to browse at their leisure – and AccessAlly enhances the experience with product thumbnails, intuitive design options, and a handy feature that lets your users know if they’ve already purchased the course.

6. Pricing and affordability

Whether you’re starting from scratch or expanding an existing online business, AccessAlly has a range of affordable pricing plans to suit different budgets and needs.

A successful membership site can facilitate growth and provide an effective eLearning experience for your customers – and AccessAlly can help you get started. 

Using AccessAlly’s course builder to create members-only content is straightforward and intuitive. 

An effect site will also help you attract and retain members, navigate potential obstacles, and check off your business goals.

Creating engaging members-only content

The success of your site can hinge upon the quality of your content – it’s the primary value proposition of a membership site, after all. 

Providing high-quality content attracts new users and reassures existing members that you’re dedicated to providing the best learning experience possible.

Creating content that maintains high standards can be complicated, however. 

Let’s take a look at a few ways you can ensure your material remains engaging:

  1. Understand your target audience and their needs: This includes learning preferences and potential areas of concern. Understanding these aspects will help you create well-rounded content that addresses audience concerns and provides value.
  2. Create a content plan and schedule: A schedule provides consistent content delivery, benefiting learners who are self-pacing their digital education, and also gives your audience something to look forward to!
  3. Offer a mix of content formats: Incorporate articles, webinars, podcasts, and more, to cater to different learning styles.
  4. Focus on quality over quantity: Creating high-quality content can increase membership engagement and retention.
  5. Ensure content is up-to-date and relevant: Keep your audience’s needs in mind and regularly update and refresh materials. This will also maintain your course’s value and appeal to new members.
  6. Encourage member interaction and feedback: Foster a sense of community, and increase loyalty, by encouraging interaction and feedback from your members.

AccessAlly’s membership features can help course creators and educators maintain these best practices:

  • Create paid-for and free membership levels: Offer different membership tiers, catering to various audience needs and budgets.
  • Drip-release content: Content can be released depending on when members join, keeping it evergreen.
  • Sell past content individually: Sell past content on an individual basis, ensuring your previous work continues to generate revenue and doesn’t go to waste.

Ditch the duct tape with AccessAlly for WordPress.

Run your online courses, memberships, coaching programs, and communities in one place.

Duct tape See it in action

Effective marketing strategies for membership sites

To promote and grow your membership site, you’ll need to implement various marketing strategies that consider the learner’s needs – whether you’re attracting new users or retaining existing ones. 

You can effectively market and promote your membership site by employing both organic and paid strategies. 

Below, we’ve explored some of the most effective ways of marketing your site.

1. Content marketing

Creating valuable eLearning content that helps learners achieve their goals is essential – it’ll attract new users and keep existing ones subscribed to your service. 

Plus, developing high-value and sharable content is a great way to showcase your own expertise and position yourself as a subject matter expert.

2. Social media marketing

Social media allows you to interact with your audience and build a community around your membership platform. 

This can involve responding to comments and messages (on networking sites like Facebook and LinkedIn), asking for feedback, and initiating conversations around relevant topics.

Social media marketing also helps your content reach a wider audience, driving new organic traffic to your site.

3. Email marketing

Whether you’re promoting a blog post, video, or course, email marketing can help spread the word. 

In addition, it’s possible to nurture leads with targeted emails (with offers or pertinent information about your service) and ultimately transform them into paying members.

Existing members will also benefit from ongoing support, as site owners can send emails containing exclusive content, one-time promotions, or invitations to a members-only area!

4. Paid advertising

Paid advertising channels such as Google Ads and social media ads can target specific demographics, interests, app behaviors, and geographic locations. 

This precision makes it much easier to ensure your intended target audience sees your ads, and boosts membership sign-ups.

It’s also worth considering advertising a lead magnet, like a free taster course for non-members, to attract new sign-ups. 

There’s a low barrier to entry, and you’ll immediately showcase the value of your course content to a fresh batch of learners!

5. Partnerships and collaborations

By partnering with influencers, industry experts, or complementary businesses, you can position your membership site as a credible and authoritative source of information in the industry. 

As a result, you’ll improve your trust within those industry circles and even extend your reach to attract new members who may have yet to be aware of your offerings.

Affiliate marketing spend has been growing year on year, too, indicating its effectiveness when incorporated into a marketing campaign.

6. SEO

You could also leverage search engine optimization to increase the visibility of your membership site and attract organic traffic. 

Optimizing content (and its structure) can improve its ranking in search engine results pages (SERPs) and attract more potential members to the platform.

However, as many membership sites rely on video content rather than written articles, this strategy may not be overly effective.

7. Popups

Popups leverage attention-grabbing visuals, targeted messaging, and incentives to encourage users to sign up for memberships.

You can get creative with your popups, too, and include information on deals and discount codes, or use data like page views, geolocation, or other user behavior to generate customized messaging for different audience segments.

We’d recommended the PopupAlly WordPress plugin – an easy-to-use solution that works seamlessly with AccessAlly. 

This powerful duo can quickly develop an email list you can use alongside your marketing campaigns.

And that’s not all! AccessAlly has its own eCommerce tools and marketing features that support the marketing of your membership site:

  • Automated email reminders: Keep customers engaged with gated content by setting up automated reminders.
  • Personalized marketing emails: Target specific audience segments for a tailored experience.
  • Affiliate program: Create a fully-tracked affiliate program with multiple tiers as part of a cost-effective marketing strategy.
when you create a membership website you build loyalty and trust with members

Building loyalty and trust with members

Loyalty and trust are two critical ingredients in the recipe for a successful membership site – particularly in the long term. 

What’s more, maintaining a thriving, profitable platform means addressing the challenge of member retention and engagement.

Below, we’ve listed our tips and best practices for nurturing lasting relationships with learners.

1. Provide exceptional customer support

Members need to know that their issues, questions, and queries will be solved promptly and effectively. 

As a result, you’ll need a well-trained support team equipped to address member concerns in a responsive, empathetic manner.

2. Encourage member interaction

Using forums or social media groups is a great way to encourage your members to interact. 

This gives users a chance to share their insights and can create a sense of belonging and online community – and in turn, the camaraderie can improve member satisfaction and loyalty.

3. Gathering and acting on member feedback

Listening to members’ needs and preferences, and adapting your membership site’s offerings accordingly, is essential. 

Regularly gather feedback and make improvements to demonstrate your commitment to meeting learner needs.

4. Offering exclusive benefits and rewards

Exclusive perks, discounts, and bonuses can be leveraged to improve loyalty, customer retention, and renewal rates

In addition, these incentives can make your membership site more appealing and help maintain long-term member relationships.

5. Communicating regularly and transparently

Be sure to utilize newsletters, email updates, or social media posts to maintain an open conversation with your members. 

Regular and transparent communication helps build trust and keeps members informed about any changes or updates to the site.

AccessAlly can help you build a thriving digital community with its suite of features:

  • Gamification: Progress tracking, points systems, and rewards can keep learners motivated and engaged with your content – and they make the whole experience more enjoyable!
  • Increased Member Retention: Personalized automations (and gamification elements) can leverage user preferences and feedback to deliver a tailored user experience and ultimately improve retention rates and the long-term success of your membership site.

Start your successful membership site with AccessAlly today

Creating an effective, authoritative membership site can be a labor of love – but it’s well worth it. 

You’ll need to pick the right membership model, create informative content with consistently high standards, and develop a marketing strategy to ensure that learners worldwide benefit from your expertise. 

Fortunately, AccessAlly can help you through the process of making, selling, and managing your membership site and members-only content.

With AccessAlly, you can take advantage of the following key features:

  1. Choose the right membership business model with the help of AccessAlly’s easy-to-use course builder.
  2. Select the perfect platform or plugin by opting for AccessAlly’s comprehensive functionality and ease of use.
  3. Create engaging members-only content using AccessAlly’s user-friendly course builder and cross-selling member dashboards.
  4. Implement effective marketing strategies, including maximizing revenue with AccessAlly’s one-click upsells.
  5. Build loyalty and trust with members through personalized automation and gamification features offered by AccessAlly.

AccessAlly is suitable for all sorts of customers, too, including entrepreneurs, small business owners, content creators, and educators. 

Whether you’re an experienced WordPress site owner or just taking your first steps, the plugin’s solutions can help you achieve your business goals and create a thriving membership site.

So, why wait? 

Take advantage of powerful tools and resources to build, sell, and grow your online courses, coaching, or membership offerings. 

Explore AccessAlly and begin creating your successful membership site today!

Ditch the duct tape with AccessAlly for WordPress.

Run your online courses, memberships, coaching programs, and communities in one place.

Duct tapeSee it in action

You might also like...